Hepatotoxicity in Drug Development

Liver toxicity has been one of the most common reasons for drug withdrawal in the past e.g Benoxaprofen (Oraflex), ticrynafen (Selacryn), bromfenac (Duract) and troglitizone (Rezulin). It has lead to black box warning for drugs like rifampicin, acetaminophen, valproic acid etc, due to their potential to cause liver injury. In some cases, drugs have not been approved because of its hepatotoxicity. Acetaminophen is a classic example where drug induced liver injury (DILI) is observed due to overdosage. The mechanism involves formation of a highly reactive metabolite N-Acetyl-p-benzoquinoneimine, by cytochrome P450 enzymes (CYPs) CYP2E1, CYP1A2, and CYP3A4. Accumulation of this metabolite results in cell death and hepatocellular necrosis. Patients with acetaminophen hepatotoxicity are treated with N-acetylcysteine, but still approximately 500 patients die each year.

In the course of drug discovery and development, why is it difficult to determine the potential of a new chemical entity to cause hepatotoxicity or DILI? Though every compound undergoes rigorous testing in animal models and in vitro hepatocytes, most of the compounds pass through without being identified as hepatotoxic, probably due to lack of an appropriate model or due to differences in absorption, distribution, metabolism, elimination (ADME) between humans & animals. Other reasons include age, sex, genetic polymorphisms, disease conditions, drug -food and drug-drug interactions (CYP Induction/Inhibition). All these factors decrease the predictive power of non-clinical studies.

An increase in levels of the liver enzymes like alanine aminotransferase (ALT) and aspartate aminotransferase (AST), alkaline phosphatase (ALP) and total bilirubin are signs of liver toxicity. Evaluation of these enzymes are routinely performed in clinical trials to assess drug induced liver injury. According to FDA guidance document, Hy’s Law (Hy Zimmerman) in determining DILI cases have the following three components:

“1. The drug causes hepatocellular injury, generally shown by more frequent 3-fold or greater elevations above the ULN of ALT or AST than the (nonhepatotoxic) control agent or placebo.
2. Among subjects showing such aminotransferase (AT) elevations, often with ATs much greater than 3xULN, some subjects also show elevation of serum TBL to >2xULN, without initial findings of cholestasis (serum alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity >2xULN).
3. No other reason can be found to explain the combination of increased AT and TBL, such as viral hepatitis A, B, or C, preexisting or acute liver disease, or another drug capable of causing the observed injury.”

If a patient has found to have AT 3xULN or TBL is greater than 2xULN, the tests need to be repeated within 48-72 hours to confirm the abnormalities.

A recent example of hepatotoxicity observed in a new drug and the response of FDA has been cited in a white paper formulated for the workshop “Assessing and Accelerating Development of Biomarkers for Drug Safety” as follows

“A major pharmaceutical company submitted an NDA application for treatment of a chronic disease. The FDA agreed with the sponsor’s efficacy data. However, it was noted that among ~4,000 treated patients in clinical trials, two developed elevations in both serum alanine aminotransferase and bilirubin. As a prerequisite for approval, the company was told to conduct a new safety study of 10,000 patients treated with drug for one year, and to also include an additional 10,000 subjects receiving comparator treatment for one year. This news will cost the company >$200M to conduct the trial, ~3 years off patent, and loss of market entry position in class.”

This clearly shows how important it is to determine the toxicity to liver during the phases of drug development. I guess this post will stimulate some fruitful discussions and ideas related to DILI.

Other Guidances/References: EMEA -Non-Clinical Guideline On Drug-Induced Hepatotoxicity[PDF], FDA White Paper on Nonclinical Assessment of Potential Hepatotoxicity in Man [PDF]

Please feel free to share this post on technocrati , del.ici.ous and digg.